top of page

Government vs Private Consulting: Salary, Hours, Lifestyle

Writer's picture: Khushi GoyalKhushi Goyal

Shatakshi Sharma, St Stephens College, University of Delhi Graduate, ISB MBA, strategist to government of India, former BCG management consultant, advisor to tony blair institute, ivy league exchange student, LinkedIn Top Voice and co-founder of Global Governance Initiative

Career Insights by GGI is a new series by GGI sharing hacks and tips around management consulting, MBA, product management and public policy.


In this GGI career insight, we will be sharing insights into: the various facets of working in the Government of India as opposed to the private sector.

 

Have you ever thought, what are the realities of working in the Government of India?


If you wish to get more information on working with the government of India in a lateral advisory role, then look no further. This career insight is going to help you understand, end-to-end, what it is like to work in this role.


1. Why did I join the Government of India?


If I were to be honest, at the age of 24, I wanted to pivot my career.


After working at a boutique management consulting firm and a leading start-up, I realised that I no longer wanted to work to make the rich richer.


I was more inclined towards a role which was at the intersection of decent wealth, a lot of learning and high impact.


I got lucky as the placement cell of my alma mater reached out to me about this job opening. After 3 interview rounds, I was able to work in the Ministry of Commerce.


2. Realities of working in the Government of India?



2.1 People you work with


On a daily basis, I was working with secretaries, joint secretaries, etc. They were all rank holders in UPSC exams.


I used to work with the current chief secretary of GoI. To date I admire her a lot, she’s the iron lady to me.


Having said that, I used to work with non-IAS officers as well like deputy secretary, undersecretary, etc.


2.2 Meetings


I realised that not all meetings were very fruitful as they lacked agenda and clear next steps.


But, it largely depended on the people charing those meetings. The lady I previously mentioned made sure that after every meeting there were clear goals, next steps and owners.


2.3 Grey-hair matters


Having worked in the private sector, I speak from experience that in such organisations, what matters is merit, data, innovation and best practices.


However, at times, in the public sector grey hair mattered. More weightage was given to what the senior most officials were saying even though they did not share their reasoning behind it.


2.4 Respect and Culture


As much as I am on board with respecting everyone, there is a stark difference in the public sector in referring to people as “sir” or “ma’am”


In the private sector, I used to call all my bosses by their first name.


I personally have a lot of dissonance with the sir-ma’am culture because that is when you put them on a pedestal. This is when innovation stops and you have inhibitions before sharing your ideas.


I find this to be a very colonial way of working in the twenty-first century.


2.5 Working Hours


Do you actually work 9-5?


I’ve realised that if there is a mission-mode project, if there is criticality, public sector employees don’t just curtail themselves to 9-5 like private sector employees.


2.6 Skill building


In government, a little less focus was put on relevant skills than in private.


Though, the government is coming up with a lot of schemes to up-skill the young generation of the country.


Had the civil servants been sufficient in future skills such as emerging technologies, data, benchmarking information and thinking prom a holistic point of view, them lateral advisors wouldn’t have been required.


2.7 Work Projects



One of the main projects I worked on was the digitization of the paperwork in the GoI. It may sound mundane, but I am very proud of my work on the project.


I was promoted to become project manager where I was responsible for setting processes, sharing best practices, and setting monitoring and outcome practices. We were able to digitise more than 34 central ministries.


2.8 Salary and Perks


I joined this role at an associate level and my starting salary was 45,000 Rs per month.


It was a contractual role which could increase as much as I wanted because of my good performance.


After 9 months, my salary was revised to 60,000 Rs per month.


Then I was promoted and my salary looked like some 80,000 per month.


I genuinely believe that for a pre-MBA with 3-4 years of experience, this was good money.


3. How can you get a job in GoI?


You can work for GoI through direct and indirect methods.


A direct approach would be through NITI AAYOG, Quality Council of India, Andhra Government, Punjab Government, Maharashtra Government, Chhattisgarh government, Haryana Government, etc.


An indirect approach would be through BCG- Public Sector Advisory, Dalberg, Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, UNDP, World Bank, UN, etc.


If you need more help getting into management consulting and product management, feel free to check out my education venture- Global Governance Initiative. We invite industry leaders to host Masterclasses and teach our students the hard and soft skills required to excel in their careers.

 

Author: Shatakshi Sharma, Co-CEO Global Governance Initiative, Ex-BCG Management Consultant, Former Policy Advisor, Tony Blair Institute for Global Change

If you are interested in learning about GGI's MBA Scholar program, you can learn here.



 
 
 

Comments


Frequently Asked Questions

1. Which program is the best fit for me?

Global Governance Initiative is removing barriers to high-quality learning experiences. 

A. You can access free recorded MBA in 10 minutes series here on the Trinity which will allow you to directly learn MBA lessons in 10 minutes from an Ex BCG consultant on Strategy/Finance/Operations etc. free of cost. 

 

B. GGI MBA Scholars- Serves as a classic Alt MBA & Pre MBA, designed specifically for those who wish to pivot their career into management consulting, business strategy, and product management

C. GGI Impact Fellowship-  Serves as a classic experiential learning and work-study model, designed specifically for those who are exploring Plan B for Civil Services and looking to pivot their career into management/impact consulting and policy as you work on projects with mentors from MBB

D. GGI Policy Scholars- Serves as a classic Alt MPP & Pre MPP, designed specifically for those who wish to pivot their career into the public policy and development sector

 

2. How can I become a GGI Impact fellow?

You can apply directly to the Impact Fellowship Program.  The selection for the impact fellowship is more competitive than the Scholars program. GGI Impact Fellowship is our Executive Crème de la crème of the Global Governance Initiative network on "Wiggly". Through core Masterclasses, flexible curriculum, and impact consulting style projects - Impact Fellowship provides a deep dive into the world of social impact consulting, and international development. It is also more expensive than the Scholars program.  

3. What are the program fees?

Our competitors charge Rs. 3,00,000 to Rs. 7,00,000. So we decided to try crazy pricing. We are 80% cheaper than our competitor's price. We are doing this because we want to make high-quality business and policy education truly accessible to you all and disrupt the space. 

 

Or if you don't want to commit, we have no questions ask full refund policy within 6 days of enrollment payment, i.e. if you are selected ( we have <10% selection rate). Either way, you win. To get detailed pricing and information, it is accessible on our application page here

4. What are the program reviews?

Find the life after GGI stories here 

5. What are GGI Masterclasses?

We at GGI provide the world's most practical Live and Interactive 9 practical Masterclasses driven by CEOs and Top Industry Professionals. The 9 practical Harvard-style real case-driven practical Masterclasses come along with the GGI Scholars & Fellows Program and are built to help you pivot into your dream careers. They are- 

  1. CV Review & Case Interview Prep Masterclass, 

  2. The MBA for Impact Masterclass

  3. Management Consulting & Sustainability Masterclass, 

  4. Management Communication Masterclass, 

  5. Policy Consulting Masterclass, 

  6. Product Management & Tech Ethics Masterclass, 

  7. Impact Investing & Entrepreneurship Masterclass, 

  8. Data Analytics & Emerging Technologies Masterclass, 

  9. The Liberal Arts Masterclass

 

During the 9 hours, community members solve cases with the speaker and amongst themselves to build foundational business, policy, and product learnings. 

 

You can access all these 9 practical Masterclasses by applying for GGI MBA Scholars program here-

6. What are the hiring opportunities via GGI Programs?

GGI also has actively partnered with top hiring consulting/policy/product management partners such as Samagra Governance, Sattva Consulting, BCG Social Impact, Leading Tech Ventures in the space of social impact, consulting, and product management roles. 

 

These hiring partners trust the GGI selection and learning process because of which they periodically hire from the close community of the Global Governance Initiative! If selected, you'd be invited for sessions by our hiring partners periodically and invited to submit your applications by our employers. 

 

To become part of the special hiring pool, you can apply to GGI MBA Scholars Program here.

7. How can I work for GGI?

We are always looking for diverse young professionals adept with technology, content, media, and operations roles. If interested, please apply here.  If we are actively hiring and you are shortlisted, we will reach out to you automatically later. 

  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
bottom of page